Shop Press

Shop Press is the news and idea hub for everything related to working on cars and trucks, focusing on repair, technology, and wrenching lifestyle.

From the creative minds at:

FEATURE STORY

Hot Off the Press

Technicians vs. DIYers: How well can you gauge tire pressure? (VIDEO)

Description After seating the bead on a new tire, the valve core needs to be installed and the tire inflated to the correct pressure. Some techs can air up a tire, install the core and land right on the target final pressure… but it’s not as easy as it looks. In this...

Smarter, not harder: relative compression testing

Pete Meier, one of our Dorman Training Center instructors, is a pretty smart cat. Since the day I’ve met him, he’s made it clear that the lab scope is one of his favorite tools and that not using one is a mistake. Now I’ve put a lot of miles on my DVOM over the years,...

Can’t break that crank bolt loose? You need a crank socket (VIDEO)

How to test for blown fuses in a car or truck | Fast and easy method Description Crank fasteners are often a real pain to remove. And sometimes, even expensive impact wrenches and large breaker bars struggle to remove them. A crank socket is just the ticket for these...

So you want to restore a classic or build a kit car? Think twice.

For reasons that have more to do with personality than pragmatism, I recently considered anew the possibility of restoring a classic car, or perhaps building a kit car. It’s an itch I’ve thought about scratching since the days when Popular Mechanics regularly featured...

EGR system – ASE practice questions (VIDEO)

Description Under what conditions would the EGR system be expected to be operational?A) Cold engine, full throttle B) Hot engine, idle C) Hot engine, full throttle D) Hot engine, part throttleMore ASE Practice Questions

A low-tech favor you can perform for every customer (and yourself)

In the modern age, it’s plenty easy to pull a vehicle’s service history; even the smallest shops have implemented shop management software. Paper tracking has become less and less important as time has marched on. Similarly, customers are less and less likely to keep...

The story of the very first reverse gear in an American car

by | Dec 26, 2023

Making a car go backwards was not the most important part of the automobile’s development, but it sure is important in its operation. In fact, if the average automobile enthusiast was to guess which American-built car had the first reverse gear, he or she would likely say it was an early Ford model. In fact, that’s what I would have said if you asked me a few months ago. But then I had a random chat with my buddy Jack Ball, who shared with me a story about his great-grandfather, Frederic J. Ball, and the car he built more than a century ago: the Ball Tonneau Touring Car.
Leaking oil plug

The Ball Tonneau Touring Car in The Horseless Age magazine, 1902. Source: Jack Ball.

Frederic J. Ball was born in Brooklyn, New York, in 1867. After graduating college, he became an apprentice machinist at the shop where his father was a partner, Ball and Jewell. Later, Ball and his father bought out the company and changed the name to G.M. Ball and Son. The company was completely controlled by Frederic Ball by 1898, at which point he changed its name to the New York Gear Works.

Leaking oil plug

Frederic J. Ball. Source: Jack Ball.

In 1902, Frederic Ball invented what he called the “spur planetary reverse gear,” which had two forward speeds and a reverse gear. An avid seafarer, Ball originally sold these gears to be installed in boats. He then manufactured an automobile he named after himself, the Ball Tonneau Touring Car, with his spur planetary reverse transmission installed. He built six of these Ball cars as one-offs in his garage in Brooklyn, making them the first American-built cars with a reverse gear. On top of that, his gear was efficient and had a low cost of manufacture. Ball patented his reversing gear invention under patent number 671,747 on April 9, 1901, and began selling his cars (he also received subsequent patents in 1904 for the reversing mechanism under patent numbers 749,516 and 749,602).

He received a decent amount of attention for this in the emerging automotive community, even having an article written about his car in the December 17, 1902, issue of The Horseless Age magazine. (Yes, that is the actual name of the magazine. Obviously, car mags had much more whimsical names in the early 20th century.) As such, he soon caught the attention of Henry Ford and John Wanamaker. They approached him with an offer to purchase the rights to his spur planetary reverse gear, but he declined. Soon after this, Frederic’s shop was broken into, and his spur planetary reverse gear plans were stolen.

In 1903 the first Ford Model A cars (an early Model A that is different from the later ’27-’31 car that most people are familiar with) were sold in all Wanamaker stores, and Ball believed that they utilized the function of his mechanism in their transmissions, since it bore striking similarity to the reverse gear that he had designed and patented. After seeing the car, Ball began to surmise that the robbery in his workshop represented the theft of more than a simple set of drawings but instead the theft of his company’s future, and he sued Wanamaker for patent infringement. Unfortunately, Frederic was forced to drop his suit in 1905 due to a lack of funds. However, that same year, he signed two licensing agreements, one from Ford Motor Company and one from Buick Motor Company, allowing use of the spur planetary reverse gear he had devised. According to the agreements, both Ford and Buick were to pay Ball one dollar for every transmission manufactured by the companies containing Ball’s patented improvements.

Leaking oil plug

Frederic J. Ball’s patent for his reversing gear.

Unfortunately, according to Jack, his great-grandfather never saw one dollar from either Ford or Buick. The problem was exacerbated after the Ford Motor Company won the infamous Selden patent case. George B. Selden was a patent lawyer and inventor who received a patent for an automobile in 1895. He sold William C. Whitney the rights to his patent in 1899. Then Whitney and Selden collaborated to recoup royalties from other nascent automakers. For a time, they were successful. Eventually, however, Henry Ford and four other car manufacturers contested the patent infringement suit filed by Selden and Whitney.

Their legal protestations were not surprising, as every automaker had to pay a royalty to Selden and Whitney simply because they effectively patented the concept of an automobile. Initially, the court ruled in favor of Selden. However, on appeal, Ford won in 1911 and no longer had to pay royalties to Selden. Ford used his victory in this case to justify not paying the patent rights to other inventors, like Frederic J. Ball.

Leaking oil plug

New York Gear Works agreement with the Ford Motor Company, 1905. Source: Jack Ball.

Frederic did not pursue any further action against Ford or Buick, at least that Jack is aware of. This is perhaps because Frederic realized that he did not have the resources for a legal case against two large automotive corporations and recognized that Ford was emboldened by his win in the Selden patent case. Jack does have a letter that Frederic wrote to Henry Ford II later in the early 1950s, where he attempted to receive recompense. In this letter that appears to be a “Hail Mary,” Frederic’s desperation in trying to collect from Ford is clear. After relaying the history of his invention, patent, and lawsuit against the elder Ford, he states, “I have been a good loser for nearly 50 years. The use of this transmission, because of its low cost of manufacture and efficiency, had a great deal to do with the success of the Ford Motor Co. I think it would be fair and proper to give me some remuneration. Do you not agree that there is a moral obligation? I invented the transmission and Henry Ford never paid me for its use. I have been informed that during the life of these patents the Ford Co. made three million cars. Hoping you will consider this matter in a favorable light.”
Leaking oil plug
New York Gear Works ad in The Horseless Age magazine, 1902. Source: Jack Ball.
Leaking oil plug
The Ball Tonneau Touring Car. Source: Jack Ball.

Unfortunately, this letter did not garner a response, and Frederic J. Ball died January 18, 1958, in Paterson, NJ, having never seen a dollar from Ford or Buick. And the six Ball cars that were built? Jack is not aware of the whereabouts of any of them, or if any even survived. He was contacted at one point by someone who claimed to have the transmission from one of the cars, but the lead vanished as quickly as it arrived.

Obviously, as this story shows, there was much to be hammered out in terms of automobile patents in the early days of the car. Those patent issues have existed in some form through the automobile history. In fact, on this very site, we discussed the struggles of Robert Kearns, who patented an intermittent windshield wiper 45 years ago. Kearns’ story was even made into a major motion picture, “Flash of Genius,” which serves to emphasize the drama that occurs and the alleged dishonesty and shady backroom dealings that are suspected in pursuit of keeping the unstoppable march of technology moving forward. Perhaps someday Frederic will receive similar recognition for his groundbreaking invention. Maybe this article will even help in that endeavor! In the meantime, the only thing Jack has from his grandfather today is ironically the only thing Frederic ever got from his pioneering invention—the pride in it.

The articles and other content contained on this site may contain links to third party websites. By clicking them, you consent to Dorman’s Website Use Agreement.

Related Articles

Shop Press Comment Policy

Participation in this forum is subject to Dorman’s Website Terms & Conditions. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline feedback
View all comments

Get Articles In Your Inbox

Subscribe to receive a monthly email summary of our latest Shop Press stories.

Shop Press

I agree to the above privacy statement and T&Cs

Thanks! You're now subscribed.