Shop Press

Shop Press is the news and idea hub for everything related to working on cars and trucks, focusing on repair, technology, and wrenching lifestyle.

From the creative minds at:

FEATURE STORY

Hot Off the Press

The importance of testing engine coolant (VIDEO)

How to test for blown fuses in a car or truck | Fast and easy methodDescription Dorman Training Center instructor Pete Meier explains why you should be testing engine coolant on vehicles in your bay. With a simple test strip, you can quickly check the coolant's health...

How to use a refractometer

I used to feel real dumb when I didn’t know what a tool was. After fixing things for a bit, I have come to learn that there are a lot of specialized tools and the only dumb thing is not learning about them. So when Dorman Trainer Pete Meier showed up recently with a...

Transfer cases: Married vs. divorced FAQ (VIDEO)

There is a paucity of divorced transfer cases fitted to vehicles traversing the roadways in 2024. In fact, some technicians—especially younger ones—aren’t even aware a setup beyond the married arrangement exists. If you’re unfamiliar with them, our own Technical...

New to the team but not new to the business (VIDEO)

Greetings, Shop Press readers! I joined the Dorman team earlier this year and you may have already noticed a few posts with my name on them. Maybe you’re even asking yourself “What makes this guy qualified to offer an opinion or try to tell me how to work on cars?”...

Square drive: make or buy before you need ‘em

As a new tech, all I did was borrow tools from mechanics who were good to me. They usually lent and trained me on etiquette just after. (If you need to borrow it more than once or twice, maybe you ought to buy your own.) It’s not that often that I find myself without...

Watch this video on the invention of the Ford V-8 engine

If you enjoy pioneering developments in automobile history, this video on the development of Ford’s V8 engine is a must-watch. It’s a bit on the long side (a little over an hour), but it’s well worth your time to fully appreciate this revolutionary success in Ford—and...

How to crimp heavy gauge wire (VIDEO)

Description Working on some battery cables or custom ground straps? Your crimped connection needs to be totally reliable, and with a proper tool like Dorman’s 90707 heavy lug crimper, you’ll get secure and consistent results. This crimper also happens to work well...

Can the flat rate system work better for a team?

by | Apr 26, 2022

If you’ve been working in an automotive shop for longer than about fifteen minutes, you know what the flat-rate system is and how it works. The system promotes some behaviors and disincentivizes some others—for better or for worse. Over the years, I have become pretty convinced that the flat-rate system works better for teams than it does for individual techs. Here’s why.

Open toolbox in an auto repair shop

Being a solo virtuoso is fine and dandy, but perhaps there is some strength in numbers, eh? Photo by Lemmy.

In most shop environments, techs are divvied up by skill level—A, B, and C are the common designations a tech receives throughout his or her career. For conversation’s sake, it should probably be hashed out roughly what we’re speaking about here. C-level techs can replace some parts on a vehicle. A-level techs will be capable of replacing most or all parts on a vehicle, but also correctly troubleshooting and diagnosing failures in complex systems. B-level techs sit in the middle somewhere, of course. (I’d also like to go on record as saying that those are not judgments of a tech’s value, just their ability. I’ve known some phenomenally driven techs who were not A-level. We’ll talk about one in a bit.)

I may be generalizing a bit here, but A-level techs skew a little older, primarily because to be an A-level tech one needs experience, and experience takes a little time. On the other end of the spectrum, we have techs who are usually light on skill and ability, but ideally have higher-than-average motivation to succeed in the field, a willingness to please, and often a strong back. (C-techs often are a bit younger due to that experience thing, and the pay rate for a C-tech isn’t always “raise a family on this” wages.)

There’s not much motivation for an A-level mechanic to train a C-level tech—he’d be slowing down his work and earning less money, and to what end? To create another tech in the shop who can take those jobs off his schedule? And the B-level tech is in a similar quandary. Thus, in most shops, the lube rack is populated by C-level techs who sometimes wind up leaving for the opportunity to move up as a B-tech in a different shop.

A C-level tech takes on more of the not-so-desirable jobs than the A has to. (Rank has its privileges.) LOFs and tire mounting/rotation come to mind for the C-level techs. Some of the more aggressive B-level jobs are no walk in the park either, like hanging exhausts and beating on rust-frozen front-end parts. However, if a car comes in for a timing belt change and a set of tires, no A-tech in the world is going to turn that ticket down—but rolling four wheels and four tires to the tire machine and back and lacing the discarded tires in the stack is definitely not the money-making end of that repair ticket. Heck, sometimes just scrabbling on a cold floor in the winter to set the lift pads is hard on old bones.

Young automotive technician

Miriam is an intern supplementing her theoretical knowledge with practical experience under the tutelage of seasoned mechanics here at Dorman. Photo by Mike Apice.

Here is where a tech team comes in. An A-tech with a lift bay next to a C who can promptly shuttle cars into the shop, rack the vehicles, and handle oil changes and rotations will likely have good reason to help his neighbor become a better wrench. It won’t be long before that C-tech moves up to tasks like fluid exchanges and more complex parts replacement because the junior wrench will have helped the senior one move faster and turn more hours. The trade gets passed along, and no one gets stiffed.

Whether A/B, A/C, B/C, or A/B/C, turning all of the jobs in the shop into team efforts promotes knowledge transfer to the less-experienced techs, and the cost of their tuition is physical labor—sweat equity. Remember that tech I told you about at the beginning of this article? I knew a pair of techs, one A and one B who worked as a team and had for years. The A-tech was a wizard diagnostician, and the B-tech was able to turn wrenches at a blinding pace. The A-guy would diag everything and pass it off, and both mechanics were pretty happy with this arrangement.

THree techs standing in an automotive shop

Better together? Maybe it’s a little corny, but sums can be greater than the parts. Photo by Mike Apice.

Whether this team approach gets implemented at a shop level or individually between willing techs, there’s something to be said for having multiple sets of eyes on a vehicle. A switch to this system sets the table for a tech being able to work past physical prime by removing some of the physical limitations of this line of work. I think a budding mechanic will get up to speed faster in a controlled environment to boot, lengthening an automotive career on both ends, which is probably significant given the existing paucity of good mechanics.

Give it a try. What do you have to lose?

 

The articles and other content contained on this site may contain links to third party websites. By clicking them, you consent to Dorman’s Website Use Agreement.

Shop Press Comment Policy

Participation in this forum is subject to Dorman’s Website Terms & Conditions. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline feedback
View all comments

RECENT ARTICLES

How to use a refractometer

How to use a refractometer

I used to feel real dumb when I didn’t know what a tool was. After fixing things for a bit, I have come to learn that...

Get Articles In Your Inbox

Subscribe to receive a monthly email summary of our latest Shop Press stories.

Shop Press

I agree to the above privacy statement and T&Cs

Thanks! You're now subscribed.