Shop Press

Shop Press is the news and idea hub for everything related to working on cars and trucks, focusing on repair, technology, and wrenching lifestyle.

From the creative minds at:

FEATURE STORY

Hot Off the Press

ASE test prep requires more than sample questions (VIDEO)

Description Do you have a study guide to prepare for your ASE exams? Which parts of that study guide do you use the most? Dorman Training Center instructor Pete Meier explains why you need to look at more than the sample question section in the back of the...

The TPMS tool that pays for itself

If you’re a regular Shop Press reader, you’ve met Chris before. (He’s hilariously identified some dash lights and also is better at identifying auto parts by feel than anyone else I know.) I’ve worked here for a while, but his tenure bests mine. The other day we were...

Tapping V6 – ASE practice questions (VIDEO)

Description Two technicians are examining a tapping sound coming from a V6 engine. Technician A says the noise could be caused by a bent pushrod. Technician B says the noise could be caused by escaping exhaust gas. Who is correct?More ASE Practice Questions

Buy once, cry once: Auto parts that are worth the extra cost (VIDEO)

Description We’ve all heard the expression “buy once, cry once,” and for some auto parts, those are words of wisdom. For others, the extra costs are unnecessary, and economical parts can be used instead. It’s up to you to explain the differences to your customers....

The best explanation of a differential is from 1937

The first time I saw this video, I was hooked because I’m natively a bike guy and it starts off with motorcycle stunt riding. But the guys horsing around on those ol’ Harley VLs actually are the producer’s interesting and educational way to visually demonstrate why a...

Rust exhaust hole – ASE practice questions (VIDEO)

Description Which of the following is the most critical result of a rust hole in an exhaust system? A) Escaping exhaust gas B) Failed inspection C) Excessive noise D) High cost of repairMore ASE Practice Questions

Before selling a vehicle, make sure to remove personal data (VIDEO)

Description Smartphones, laptops and computers are normally cleared of all data before selling or discarding to protect personal information. Modern vehicles store all kind of information in their infotainment systems and that means they should be treated with the...

Is side work OK for service techs?

by | Nov 8, 2022

Do you do side work? If you do, is that OK?

There are tons of reasons for and against doing work outside the shop. I think my views have changed a little as I’ve been in the game a little longer, but this aspect of the job is contentious. I’ve heard various rationale, some of it quite compelling. I do think it’s something worth bringing up both here and in most shop settings. I certainly have my own beliefs on the topic, and I bet you do, too—but it’s probably best if the boss and the techs are on the same page. (And the writers. This topic affects anyone in a shop who knows how to turn wrenches.)

Car on a jack

At what point does “business” become “shop business?”

The shop owner’s viewpoint

In the shop’s defense, side work pits the shop against the tech, and the shop is often at a few disadvantages. First, and most obviously, if a tech is actually walking business out of the shop, they’re actually paying the competition to compete. This is not always the case, but this version of moonlighting is especially expensive for a shop owner.

In a smaller region, a case can be made that the customer may have used the shop to perform the work if the tech was unavailable due to a lack of other, better options. A tech can travel. A shop cannot. If a geographic area is being picked clean by techs at night and they’re hitting guarantee during the day, a problem is obviously unfolding.

Ultimately, if side work hurts a shop enough to close down, one mechanic stuffing his own wallet a bit may cause a few other technicians to be without work at all, which is an ethical concern for both foremen and wrenches alike.

A mechanic works on a vehicle

Where does the shop’s claim to a customer end? Where does the mechanic’s begin?

This can be worse where items like state inspections are made artificially inexpensive by law. It’s not uncommon for a tech to perform the side work on a vehicle, and then have the customer swing by the shop to get inspected. In this scenario, both parties know full well the shop won’t get any work, but the shop will sell the inspection at a loss, not knowing the car has already been checked out and repaired.

Shop owners also rightly point out that nearly all side work is performed under the table, giving the tech an advantage percentage that’s easily in the double digits. If some or all of that cost delta is passed on to the customer, the illegitimate side work enjoys a pricing model that the shop cannot touch. Even if a tech is claiming the income on state and local taxes, he hasn’t paid a business license and thus isn’t charging and submitting sales taxes from the customer.

There is an element of overlap to consider. If a tech is tired from a previous job, left necessary equipment at home, or is injured during a moonlighting gig, the tech profits, but the shop will suffer loss of income. Consider even a shop where side work is permitted in the shop after hours. What happens if a car is damaged in the shop? What happens if a customer is hurt? In a less-serious scenario, what if a disassembled car becomes stranded on a lift, due either to a lack of time for the repair or inability to source parts after hours? All of these items directly impact the profitability of the business.

In most places, it is perfectly legal for private employers to regulate employees’ work outside of the workplace, and many shop owners avail themselves of that ability. And if a shop implements a policy prohibiting or limiting moonlighting, it does raise the question of whether that applies only to new hires or all techs. Do existing techs need to be compensated to curb the practice if implemented in the middle of employment? If they aren’t and forced out of side work, will they leave? Can the shop absorb that loss? Implementing these policies is not a cut-and-dried task.

But how about the obverse of the coin?

The mechanic’s viewpoint

Many techs feel it’s not equitable to be prohibited from legally seeking prosperity on off time, the thought being that the veil of employment should not cover all waking hours of an employee’s life. Similarly, preventing a tech from using the tools he has bought from which both he and his employer benefit doesn’t seem entirely fair, either.

Loosening a pan drain bolt.

Repair tool or Instrument of destruction? It’s all a matter of perspective.

Another item that comes up is the matter of pay plan. Most technicians are not hourly or salaried. Instead, the pay scheme for most mechanics is more akin to that of an independent contractor. Work equals pay, and no work equals no pay. (Unless there is a guarantee, which is generally not generous and usually not something most techs are expecting to hit.) If a tech is twiddling his thumbs because the shop has no work, it can be excruciating to be disallowed from leaving early to moonlight and instead scrub a shop he doesn’t own gratis.

Related to that is pay itself. Most mechanics are not highly paid, relatively speaking—the BLS says the mean wage for a mechanic as of May of 2021 was $44,720 annually. At that same time, though, the average household income was $70,784, so a mechanic in a single-income household was pretty likely to need the financial relief moonlighting income provided.

Add to this that all too many shop foremen and owners have either been out of the game long enough or never wrenched at all, and the power to fix the cars lies solely with the technician. It’s a bit of a slight, since those positions often clear similar or better money than the tech. Not only can many in the shop not perform the stated task of repairing a car, but they aren’t tooled appropriately for it and often don’t have much sympathy for the person turning the wrenches—but will happily yell to get a job done under book time or beyond quitting time.

Many techs will also make the argument that much of the work they are doing is not a choice between the shop and the moonlighting mechanic. Some mechanics will work on different equipment, like a diesel truck mechanic who moonlights on heavy equipment or agricultural equipment. Is an alignment tech really hurting a chain tire dealer if he’s installing a lift kit on a side-by-side by night?

Mechanic working on antique car

Does a shop even want business from an owner whose car demands parts that are never in stock and a tech with specialized knowledge of yesteryear?

Others point out that work on very old or specialty vehicles isn’t work most standard automotive shops want to take on anyway. Still another faction points out that when a customer is price-sensitive enough to seek out moonlight work, the shop is not even an option, but rather the choice is between a moonlighting tech servicing the vehicle or the owner.

Finally, a reasonably intelligent tech will realize the burden of discovery of policy violations lies with the employer, which means an employer must monitor an employee’s residence and/or track his off-the-clock movements. This well may fall within the boundaries of the law, but it does smack a bit of Ford’s Sociological Department. It may be permissible, but is it ethical? Normal, even?

I’m certainly not going to be an impartial arbiter of what you should do as a tech or what your shop should do. I wouldn’t be hubristic enough to think I know your shop’s situation, but I would encourage all parties to think about the ramifications of side work and at very least develop a policy—together—on it.

The articles and other content contained on this site may contain links to third party websites. By clicking them, you consent to Dorman’s Website Use Agreement.

Related Articles

Shop Press Comment Policy

Participation in this forum is subject to Dorman’s Website Terms & Conditions. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline feedback
View all comments

Get Articles In Your Inbox

Subscribe to receive a monthly email summary of our latest Shop Press stories.

Shop Press

I agree to the above privacy statement and T&Cs

Thanks! You're now subscribed.