Shop Press

Shop Press is the news and idea hub for everything related to working on cars and trucks, focusing on repair, technology, and wrenching lifestyle.

From the creative minds at:

FEATURE STORY

Hot Off the Press

Texas nonprofit helps low-income vehicle owners afford auto repairs

At any given time, about 1 in 5 vehicle owners are delaying some sort of auto repair, with the most common reason being that they can’t afford it, according to the Auto Care Association Factbook. All this deferred work adds up to an estimated $31 billion that drivers...

A day in the life of a service writer (VIDEO)

The hardest job in an automotive shop might just be that of the service writer. Taking heat from the boss, the techs, and the customers isn't easy. That the role is for dynamic individuals becomes apparent quickly when considering the tasks that make up the job. Watch...

Serviceability Hall of Shame: Ford Taurus Spring Shields

The Serviceability Hall Of Shame was born from all the times we’ve looked at a vehicle and realized some usually simple task was going to be nightmarish. It is, ultimately, a response and explanation of the inevitable question, “Good Lord, why?!” Today’s entrant isn’t...

January Automotive Horoscopes

Aries: You may not think of some of your repairs as innovative, but a creative fix is a creative fix. Your outlook is out there, and that's OK. Expect to see someone else cribbing your notes but remember to take it as flattery. Not everyone has the same gift of seeing...

It’s totally fine to run your fuel tank down to empty

One of the pieces of automotive wisdom that’s been repeated by publications and mechanics alike for ages is that it’s not good to run a fuel tank below some arbitrary fill point, like a quarter of a tank. At some point, that probably wasn’t bad advice. But today? It’s...

LOF PSA: Don’t forget the lube job

Please forgive me, because I’m about to be a dinosaur and proselytize for a few moments. Many moons ago, I would have customers request an oil change and a lube job. It was so prevalent that the acronym for this, LOF, is still in pretty common use. (That’s “lube, oil,...

Best of Shop Press 2022

Shop Press officially launched in March 2022, at least if you go by the press release. Between then and now, we’ve published well over 100 articles and videos dedicated to auto repair professionals and wrenching enthusiasts. We greatly appreciate everyone who has...

Let’s bring back this tiny piece of archaic automotive technology

by | Mar 22, 2022

In the halcyon days of the automobile, metallurgical processes were obviously cruder than they were today. Automotive lubricants were not as well-developed as modern equivalents. Because of the crummy metals and oils of the era, service was required frequently—“extended drain intervals” hadn’t been dreamt up yet. That service, generally a simple fluid exchange, was usually performed by way of removing and installing one of the humblest auto parts: the pipe plug.

Consider the many lubricated, sealed parts units on vehicles: differentials, transmissions, transfer cases, engines, gear boxes… and I’m sure I’ve missed a few. These subassemblies exist on all sorts of motorized contraptions, far beyond cars and trucks—motorcycles, tractors, ag and mining equipment, hydraulic cylinders and more.

Drain plug in an automatic transmission

Here’s the vehicle I had in the air that made me more excited than I should be. It’s not often you find a convenient drain plug on an auto trans these days. (Very bad) photo by Lemmy.

Almost uniformly, these vehicle components would come equipped with two or three plugs: drain, fill, and sometimes a level port to ease service and promote fluid exchanges. Drain and fill, of course, are obvious in their intent. Level plugs are sometimes used when a fill plug in that position would be difficult to access. Whether the housing was made of sheet metal, cast iron, or cast aluminum, it would be machined to accept those plugs.

And then they started going away. Many automatic transmissions lost their plugs a pretty long time ago. A transmission service way back when required a filter replacement and often band adjustment, both of which require dropping the pan. Do you think the auto manufacturers eschewed the plugs to save money, or was it to “encourage” lazy mechanics to complete the full service? And as time went on, lifetime fill transmissions (which I believe translates as “filled through the warranty period”) really didn’t help matters. And while it is self-serving to say so, I would note that we add drain plugs to our transmission pans because…well, adding them makes sense.

Ford 9

This Ford 9″ differential came with a filler plug, but no drain. Replacing the fluid involves either pulling the axles (and risking the attendant leak from the seal that’s been disturbed) or pulling the driveshaft and third member. Forget that. I machined both the housing and the third member for a drain plug. Photo by Lemmy.

Differentials lost them. Banjo axles, which were much more common in years gone by, needed plugs because pulling the third member or the axles was the only way to drain the diff. Once Salisbury (tube) axles became the norm, there was no longer a need to include the additional expense of those plugs.

I guess they’re not totally gone. I still see drain and fill plugs sorta regularly on manual transmissions, which themselves I no longer see regularly anymore, now that I think about it. Transfer cases are still holding out for the most part; those almost always have drain ‘n’ fill ports. (A notable exception is that braindead Ford PTU that we fixed.)

Toyota banjo-style rears, without a sheet metal access cover, proudly bear fill and drain plugs. And of course almost all engine oil pans and tanks have drain plugs.

Toyota rear

Here’s a Toyota rear on the bench, with drain and fill plugs both clearly visible. Photo by Mike Apice.

So why don’t we…like, ask for them back? I add drain plugs to all sorts of stuff. It makes life easier. Even on an auto trans where I am gonna swap the filter anyway, it’s a lot easier to unscrew a bolt than it is to try to drop a pan with three quarts of fluid in it without making a huge mess. In fact, an automatic transmission service I performed recently spurred me to write this article. I was so surprised to see a plain ol’ drain plug staring at me.

And how about diffs? It sure would be nice to pop two plugs to swap fluid on your 4×4 after an offroad junket, right? If you forgot to pick up a diff gasket, it wouldn’t matter! If the manufacturers started putting those plugs back in, labor times and prices for these basic fluid swaps would drop—maybe meaning people wouldn’t put off service for so long while they scrounge up money. And perhaps the cars might last just a bit longer.

Automotive engineers are working with price constraints, legal constraints, price constraints, forced integration with legacy parts, price constraints, consideration for ease of assembly on the line, and also price constraints. Ease of service is definitely not high on the list, especially if it drives up the price of a subassembly, no matter by how little.

But I’d like to see ‘em anyway.

Related Articles

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
7 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline feedback
View all comments
7
0
Click to leave a comment!x
()
x

Get Articles In Your Inbox

Subscribe to receive a monthly email summary of our latest Shop Press stories.

Shop Press

Thanks! You're now subscribed.