DIFM customers just won’t purchase this common underhood part.
Is it OK to plug a tire? (VIDEO)
My career started with tire repairs, and I bet yours did, too.
Depending on how many years ago that was, you may have been patching tires, plugging tires, or patch-plugging. I recall being told solemnly by my manager that I was never to plug a tire because it was dangerous. I held my tongue, but as the title of this piece no doubt tipped you off, my opinion now is the same as it was then. Pluggin’ a tire from the outside-in is just fine. We’ll get to why in a second.
Some of you are shaking your heads because I wrote something that flies in the face of what you’ve been told for a long, long time. Consider a few of the other guidelines: no repairs outside the tread grooves. Always inspect the tire liner. And several manufacturers consider a repaired tire to have a reduced or even nullified speed rating.
And all of these rules have always been promulgated by groups like the RMA (now the U.S. Tire Manufacturers Association). It does seem to me that an abundance of care would benefit them through either increased tire sales (“Sorry, that repair isn’t within the repairable zone”) or, barring that, having a damaged tire brought to a shop that presumably also (begrudgingly) repairs tires. (“You can’t repair it without dismounting!”)
I’m not saying every tire can be plugged and tossed back into service. A plug, like any repair, is not bulletproof. Much depends on the injury the tire suffered and the skill of the installer. However, my anec-data over the years has led me to believe plugs are just fine. And patches are just fine. And patch-plugs are also (you guessed it) just fine.
The argument against patches is that the tire’s steel belts are now exposed to water and salt by way of the path the offending item took into the tire, and will eventually separate, leading to a violent blowout. The argument against plugs is that they don’t seal the liner. My argument for any of these repairs is that every one I have performed has never failed, and I have done a ton of ‘em on personal vehicles and way more customer cars. (In fairness, I have never patched anything besides a tube. If I’m inside a tire, it’s getting a patch-plug.) If someone can explain to me how a patch-plug does a better job of keeping moisture and contaminants out of the tire than just the plug, I’m all ears.
Sure, there could be damage inside. And yeah, I’ve stuffed a string plug in spots outside the “repairable area.” But I also don’t run out for a trackday on my beater commuter after I have done it. They’ve worked fine on wheelbarrows, motorcycles, cars, mowers, tractors, trucks, and trailers. Heck, I think it’s easier and quicker to plug a tire roadside than it is to swap to the spare tire and wheel. And let’s also not forget string plugs were the most common tire shop repair for many, many years, and it was considered a permanent repair. (At least one tire repair kit manufacturer seems to agree that string plugs can be considered a permanent repair.)
Nightmare stories about improper tire repairs exist. However, if some of the major tire manufacturers remove speed ratings from tires repaired using any method, it sounds like at least some of them consider a “properly” repaired tire unsuitable to be returned to service. Perhaps ANY tire repair is incorrect, then, if a vehicle is to be shod with tires of a certain speed rating. And what about other damage? I’ve certainly seen some tires that have taken wicked curbshots or potholes. That can’t be great for the liner or sidewall, but do we have people running out to replace tires when that happens?
In many areas with vehicle inspection, tires are almost certainly on the list of items to be checked over. I’ve never seen a state that would fail a vehicle for having a tire plug—if they’re not safe, wouldn’t that be part of a basic vehicle safety check? The Commonwealth of Virginia even mentions plugs, specifically stating that a plug that’s been installed in the conventional repair area should not be rejected.
I’m certainly not opposed to the patch or patch-plug. I just think the plug has been villainized because… well, because the enemy of a tire sale is a plug, and most folks aren’t gonna dismount a tire to repair one at home. I think litigation (or the threat thereof) has driven tire plugging the way of the dodo bird. I wouldn’t stuff one in a customer’s tire. I wouldn’t encourage you to do that, either. But for my own stuff? Sure, why not? And for that reason alone, I’d say the tire plug isn’t done just yet.
The articles and other content contained on this site may contain links to third party websites. By clicking them, you consent to Dorman’s Website Use Agreement.
Description Think you know your dash lights? Shop Press contributors Keith, Miriam, Chris, and Greaser try their best...
“Got a seven-foot section of brake line out without dropping the tank, cutting the line, or ruining a fitting. Today...
I picked up a habit many of you probably have: I had a “Lights Buddy” (patent pending) in the shop. This was usually...