Unfortunately, after hearing a report that GM was making their vehicles smaller, Lester Lum “Tex” Colbert, Keller’s successor as president of Chrysler, ordered Exner to make the same changes to his 1962 designs. Exner objected to the modification, believing it would make his cars “ugly.” Exner and his colleagues had finished the second full-sized, finless Plymouth since 1955, this one scheduled for 1962 and praised as an incredibly beautiful car. While he was still recuperating from a recent heart attack, Exner’s 1962 models were downsized by associates. The automobiles’ look was significantly altered by this reduction. The cars were less appealing, leading to a significant decrease in sales.
The GM rumor proved to be untrue, and buyers didn’t like the smaller Plymouth and Dodge 1962 models, which had strange style in comparison to more subdued Ford and GM offerings. Chrysler fired Exner because they needed a scapegoat, but they let him stay on as a consultant. Tailfins were soon out of style. Chrysler’s “Forward Look” designs ended with the 1961 models; Exner later dubbed the smaller, finless 1962 Plymouth and Dodge models “plucked chickens.” He thought the management at Chrysler had picked away at the automobiles to reduce their price.
After being fired by Chrysler, Exner decided to pursue his passion for boating by designing boats and cabin cruisers. Eventually he worked with Buehler Turbocraft, designing their 1966 Bolero, 1966 Bar Harbor, and 1967 Express Cruiser. The Bolero was chosen by Popular Science magazine as the “Trend setter for ’66” and the Bar Harbor became one of Buehler’s top sellers. Furthermore, all of these boats are coveted today, showing that Exner’s designs clearly still resonate.
Along with his work on boats, Exner also continued to consult with car companies at this time. Starting in the 1960s, collectors began buying up old Rolls-Royce, Mercedes-Benz, and Bugatti cars. In early 1963, Exner was interviewed by Esquire magazine about this trend and how he thought it affected current and future automotive design. For the piece, Exner designed what he thought some of those older cars would look like with modern styling, which he called “Revival Car” concepts. This led to him being involved in the revival of Stutz in the 1970s as Stutz Motor Car of America, specifically his design for the 1971 Stutz Blackhawk. The Blackhawk was a hit with A-listers, owned by Elvis Presley, Frank Sinatra, and Dean Martin, and it seemed like everybody who was anybody in 1971 was trying to get one.